• Home
  • Finance
    • Financial Management
    • Strategic Management
    • Investment Analysis and Portfolio Management
    • Project Management
    • Islamic Banking & Finance
    • Auditing
  • Marketing
    • Principle of Marketing
    • Marketing Management
    • International Marketing
    • Advertising & Promotion
    • Commercial Challenges
  • HRM
    • Human Resource Management
    • Principles of Management
    • Training & Development
    • Employee Performance Management
  • Others
    • Introduction to Business
    • Business Communication
    • Banking & Finance
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Economics
  • Personal Skills
  • Tips & Tricks
  • About Us
    • Contact US

Business Study Notes

B.Com, M.Com. BBA & MBA Exam Study Online

  • Home
  • Finance
    • Financial Management
    • Strategic Management
    • Investment Analysis and Portfolio Management
    • Project Management
    • Islamic Banking & Finance
    • Auditing
  • Marketing
    • Principle of Marketing
    • Marketing Management
    • International Marketing
    • Advertising & Promotion
    • Commercial Challenges
  • HRM
    • Human Resource Management
    • Principles of Management
    • Training & Development
    • Employee Performance Management
  • Others
    • Introduction to Business
    • Business Communication
    • Banking & Finance
    • Entrepreneurship
    • Economics
  • Personal Skills
  • Tips & Tricks
  • About Us
    • Contact US
Home » What Is Capital Rationing? Give Example and Reason to Choose

What Is Capital Rationing? Give Example and Reason to Choose

By Richard Daniels Reading Time: 6 mins
Updated October 5, 2020

Capital rationing is the rationing of investments & capital among various opportunities by business organizations. Capital rationing is the practical picture of capital budgeting because the financial resources available to a certain company are limited in real-life situations.

Besides organizations, countries also perform capital rationing. For example in particular country food rationing is done. The most important criterion that is used in capital rationing for making decisions about the investment in certain projects is the Net Present Value.

Capital Rationing

Moreover, the Internal Rate of Return is the second significant criterion that is used for making such a decision. Besides these criteria, there is another standard that is best used in capital rationing called Percent Budget Utilization. This standard is related to mobilizing of a percentage of total investing available money.

Those investments are considered who’s calculated IRRs are greater than the current risk-free rate of return because of the fact that it is the desire of every company to maximize its return from its portfolio. In the practical environment, the available money to any organization is limited and the company has to spend that limited portion in different investments.

Therefore the new aspect of the analysis is considered which is capital rationing for making investments in potential projects. The investment decision is made keeping in view the size & importance of the investment options. The investment decisions which are very important & essential are taken by the CEO or the company. On the other hand, normal growth and R&D related investment decisions are made by the heads of the divisions or middle management.

Reasons for Capital Rationing

In practical scenarios, different situations come in front of the company in which it has positive NPVs & higher IRRs about projects but still, it is not possible to make an investment in them. The following are some of the reasons in this regard.

  • One big reason is that the potential project requires higher initial investment which is not possible for the organization in the light of its limited capital. So in such cases that potential project is rejected.
  • There may be a lack of relevant human resources, talent, or knowledge for the staring or operating of the new potential project. Even in such a case, the company will not invest in that project.
  • The fear of debt is another reason for the rejection of potential investment options by companies. In Muslim countries, the interest paid on debt (Riba) is considered as a major issue because of the religious constraint for Muslims in the borrowing of money on interest. Therefore in many Muslim countries, there is an ethical basis associated with capital rationing. So the investors of such Muslim countries invest in equity based projects where there is a risk of profit or loss.

Example:

The following example clearly shows how capital rationing takes place in the selection of certain investment project among groups of available options.

Suppose there are four projects (relating to real assets & are mutually exclusive) and the company has to make decisions from them in the light of its limited capital of $ 1,000.

There are four available options and a decision need to be made by management to certain projects among the pool because it is not possible for the company to start all the 4 projects because the total initial investment (Io) of the 4 projects is equal to $ 1,400 (100+300+200+800) which is greater than the total available capital of $ 1,000. So the company adopts a capital rationing procedure which is as follows.

Option 1:

If the company decides to select projects A, B & C then it has to find out the cumulative NPV of these three projects & along with the combined IRR. Finally, a special parameter of capital rationing is considered which is the percentage of total budget available being invested if the three projects are availed.

Budget Utilization = 100+300+200 = 600 (out of 1,000)

Total NPV of the three projects = 300+200+300 = 800

Simple Average IRR = (40+35+40)/3 = 38% (non-weighted)

The combined NPV of the three projects is 800 which are better as compared to the size of investments. The average IRR of 38% is also attractive. At last the percentage of budget utilized is considered which is

Budget Utilization = 100+300+200 = 600

This means that 60% of the total budget will be utilized in this option.

Now a similar process will be applied to the second and third options.

Option 2:

In this option the company select project C & D because they have the highest combined NPV.

Budget Utilization = 200+800 = 1,000

Total NPV of the two projects = 300+600 = 900

Average IRR = (40+30)/2 = 35%

Option 3:

In this option projects, A & D are selected because they also have the highest combined NPV.

Budget Utilization = 100+800 = 900

Total NPV of the two projects = 300+600 = 900

Average IRR = (40+30)/2 = 35%

Conclusion:

The summary of the Capital Rationing Process of the above three options is as follows.

Capital Rationing

From the above summary, it is clear that option 2 is the best option among all the available three options because it has the highest NPV of $ 900 while the 100% budget is utilized. It also has an average IRR of 35%.

Reason for not choosing of Option 1

In option 1, there is the highest average IRR of 38% but it has the lowest NPV from the other two options. There is another reason for not selecting option 1 which is that the utilizing budget in this option is only 60% and there is 40% remaining amount of money which cannot be utilized in any other project & hence remain idle.

This idle money can finally be deposited into a bank account for earning a minimum return of 9 to 10% because there is no other investment option for it. So it is also clear that the percent of budget utilized is very important and it must be closest to 100% in selecting an option of investment.

Kinds of Problems in Capital Rationing

There are certain problems that are part of the capital rationing technique of Capital Budgeting. These problems are as follows.

  1. Different sizes of cash flows
  2. Timing difference of cash flows
  3. Unequal (Different) lives of different projects

The difference in Size (In Investment Outlay)

The initial investment (or outlay) differences show different extents of the utilization of the budget. In such a case, two projects with different sizes of cash flows are compared. One project having larger cash flows occurring at a different point in time and others containing smaller cash flows at a regular interval of time.

If the cash flows of two projects are different then where will the leftover portion of the budget or un-utilized money be invested? The idle portion of the money is not able to generate any kind of return and hence go wasted.

Example:

Let’s suppose there are two projects A & B which have different sizes of cash flows. The total budget for the project is $ 1,500.

  1. Project A

Cash Flows:  Io = -$ 1,500,   year1 = +1,900

NPV = $ 227 (at i = 10%), IRR = 27%

  1. Project B

Cash Flows:  Io =- $ 200,   Year1 = $ 300

NPV = $ 73 (at i = 10%), IRR = 50%

If the above two projects are compared then it is reflected that the IRR of project B is higher than project A. But NPV is more important than IRR in comparing the potential of the investment options. The NPV of project A is greater than of project B therefore project A is the best option for investment. But at the same time, the IRR of project A is lower than project B because larger size cash flow is received at a later point of time in project A as compared to project B.

The difference in Timing:

A certain project that has good NPV can suffer from lower IRR. The reason behind this lowering of IRR is that there are larger cash flows are received at a later point in time.

Example:

Suppose there are two projects A and B having different timing of cash flows. The total budget of the project is $ 2,500

  1. Project A

Cash Flows:  Io = -$ 1,000, Year1 = +$ 650, Year2 = 650, Year3 = 650 (annuity)

NPV = +$ 616 (at i = 10%)   IRR = 43%

  1. Project B

Cash Flows:  Io = -$ 1,000, Year1 = +$ 100, Year2 = +$ 200, Year3 = +$ 2,000 (late large cash flow)

NPV = +$ 758 (at i = 10%)   IRR = 35%

When the above two projects are compared project B is the best option to select on the basis of higher NPV.

Different Lives Problem:

There is a situation where investment projects or assets have different lives. For example, there are two options for purchasing a printing machine by a business. One option is to purchase a new printing machine with a longer life span and the other option is to purchase a machine of a shorter lifespan. Each life span has its own advantage & disadvantage.

The disadvantage of Project with longer Life Span

The longer life span asset cannot be replaced quickly in order to update with the latest technology that lowers the costs & improves the quality of products.

The disadvantage of Project with Shorter Life Span

The money will be reinvested in other projects which do not have certain NPV & return which will make these projects risky. And if money is not invested in any project then it will be deposited into the bank at the minimum rate of return. For making comparisons of projects with different life spans EAA and Common Life approaches are used.

Author at Business Study Notes
Richard DanielsAuthor at Business Study Notes

Hello everyone! This is Richard Daniels, a full-time passionate researcher & blogger. He holds a Ph.D. degree in Economics. He loves to write about economics, e-commerce, and business-related topics for students to assist them in their studies. That's the sole purpose of Business Study Notes.
Love my efforts? Don't forget to share this blog.

Related Posts:

  • Capital Budgeting Techniques and Examples
    Capital Budgeting Techniques and Examples
  • What Is The Modified Internal Rate of Return Analysis?
    What Is The Modified Internal Rate of Return Analysis?
  • Net Present Value (NPV)
    Net Present Value (NPV)
  • What is the Process of Motivation? Explain in detail
    What is the Process of Motivation? Explain in detail
  • What Are The Types Of Project Selection Models?
    What Are The Types Of Project Selection Models?

Filed Under: Finance, Financial Management Tagged With: capital rationing example, process of capital rationing

Related Posts

System-Views-of-Management-image

System Views of Management

System Views System views of management associates with the Management division of the organization and it assumes that all of the organizations are … [Read More...]

Leadership Theories

Situational Leadership Theories

Situational Leadership Theories Situational model of leadership is a factor that emphasizes the behavior of the leaders regarding different situations. … [Read More...]

Behavioral Leadership Model

Behavioral Leadership Model

Leadership  Leadership is the most critical and complex responsibility across any organization. It is because the leadership requires to be realistic, … [Read More...]

career development process in hrm

Career Development Process

Career Development Process Today's career development process has become a threat for students, especially a question that may stun many students who have … [Read More...]

Strategic leadership

Strategic Leadership Model

Strategic Leadership Model The strategic leadership model is basically the study of the leadership style. It describes the ways of modernizing an … [Read More...]

Types of Managerial Decision Making

Types of Managerial Decision Making

Managerial Decision Making Decision Making is an art of selection of one feasible alternative decision from many. Therefore types of managerial decision … [Read More...]

Quantitative-management-approach

Quantitative Management Approach

Quantitative Management Approach The quantitative management approach is used to enhance decision making power by using quantitative tools. As well as … [Read More...]

Effective-business-messages-image

Effective Business Messages

Effective Business Messages The process through which business messages are effectively prepared that have the potential to create desired results from … [Read More...]

Search the Site

ADVERTISEMENT

Business Study Notes

Business Study Notes is all about business studies or business education. Visit us to find here free business notes of all the subjects of B.com, M.com, BBA & MBA online.

Disclaimer

All the images and videos present on the Business Study Notes are not owned by us, if you found anything under copyrights, please Contact Us, we will remove it ASAP.

Categories

© Copyright 2023 Business Study Notes. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy, Sitemap.  
DMCA
PROTECTED